Earlier this week, the two sparked dating rumors after were spotted hanging out together in Malibu, where they hit the beach for some paddleboarding fun.
A source told Us Weekly, "They were all over each other — holding hands and getting touchy-feely. They were really cute and would make a gorgeous couple."
McKinney was last romantically linked to Stephen Dorff. An insider revealed, "She is not dating Stephen Dorff any longer. They broke up a few weeks ago."