Wednesday's theme on "American Idol" was "Now & Then," and the top 5 sang one tune from the last few years and another from "back in the day," with help from a guest mentor, Sheryl Crow.
Full story on MTV
Get more "Extra" Scoop headlines for Thursday, May 5!
Pippa Middleton's Dirty Dance... in Her Bra -- UsWeekly
Video! Kim Kardashian's Great Butt Debate -- TMZ
Bar Refaeli and Leonardo DiCaprio on the Outs? -- RadarOnline
Maxim's Hot 100 Full of Mysteries -- Entertainment Weekly