A close source told Page Six, "He proposed on Sunday. It was for their anniversary." The couple have been on and off since 2012.
Another insider shared with New York Daily News, "She already has the ring. The family is very happy because they really like him.”
Earlier this year, Davis commented on the reports that she would be walking down the aisle soon. She said, "I really try not to read a lot of the stuff. It's more annoying to hear it from friends and family because I am like, 'Don't you think I would tell you if that was the case? You're not going to hear it (somewhere else).'"
The retired Yankees star recently admitted that he couldn't settle down when he was playing baseball. He told sports memorabilia dealer Brandon Steiner, "I was too selfish to be able to juggle a family and kids. But I look forward to it happening. I just know that I … couldn't have done it while I was playing."