Vote! Who Would You Like as An 'Idol' Judge?

With names like Jennifer Lopez, Steven Tyler, Justin Timberlake, Elton John, Jessica Simpson and Harry Connick Jr. being considered to join lone holdover Randy Jackson on "American Idol," "Extra" and PopEater want to know who you'd pick!

jennifer lopez jessica simpson steven tyler justin timberlake

If there's someone else you're angling for, let us know in the comments!