Pink vs. Shakira: Who Wore It Better?

Uh-oh! Songstresses Pink and Shakira showed up at the 2009 VMAs wearing the exact same Balmain studded leather dress! Both women handled the fashion faux pas with grace, even posing for pictures together.

pink shakira same dress vmas

Pink paired the dress with tall pumps and a side-swept 'do, while Shakira complemented the frock with thigh-high boots and wavy tresses.

Tell "Extra" -- Who wore it better?