VOTE: Did 'The Bachelor' Pick the Right Woman?

In a shocking "Bachelor" twist, Jason Mesnick proposed to Melissa Rycroft, and the 25-year-old sales rep happily accepted -- only to have him dump her for the other finalist, 24-year-old Molly Malaney!


Melissa stormed off the set, heartbroken, while Molly agreed to give her relationship with Jason another shot.

Tell "Extra" -- did Jason ultimately pick the right girl?

"Extra" friends couldn't believe Jason pulled a switch-a-roo on Melissa and Molly -- can you? Discuss this in our community now!